In the afternoon, the brighter atrium-style dining area at Tony's has a very open, turn of the century vibe. As night falls, Tony’s Town Square Restaurant takes on a slightly more romantic tone with an interior dining area featuring a Lady and the Tramp centerpiece fountain, depicting the cute canines. A third outdoor actual patio area provide great views of the goings on in the Main Street USA courtyard.

The all-day menu features American-Italian favorites such as Spaghetti, Ravioli, Chicken Parmigiana, and Fettuccine Alfredo. Several desserts are also on the menu, from the traditional Tiramisù and Gelato to the new "Firehouse Doughnuts" and Budino cup (which is an Italian custard or pudding type of dessert).